Pre-Employment Screening A Comprehensive Guide to Hiring the Best Candidates

As HR professionals, the pressure to identify top-notch talent that aligns perfectly with your company culture is immense. However, finding an ideal match can be daunting and uncertain. Making a single hiring mistake can drain your time, resources, and momentum, making it crucial to continually improve your talent assessment and pre-employment screening process.

In this comprehensive guide, we will walk you through the ins and outs of pre-employment screening, empowering you to make informed decisions and secure the best candidates for your organisation.

What Is Pre-Employment Screening?

Pre-employment screening, also known as background checks and applicant screening, is a vital evaluation process that employers use to gather and verify crucial information about potential hires. Its purpose is to mitigate risk, ensure workplace safety, and make well-informed hiring choices that comply with legal requirements and industry standards.

Importance of Pre-Employment Screening

Pre-hire screening is like a guiding lighthouse in the daunting task of navigating today’s treacherous hiring landscape. It helps mitigate risks, ensure compatibility, and set the stage for long-term success. Let’s explore how applicant screening processes achieve these goals.

Uncover Key Candidate Information

To ensure that every hire counts, you need to go beyond the surface-level information presented in resumes and interviews. Pre-hire screening allows you to unveil valuable information about candidates that goes beyond the glossy surface of their resumes and interviews.

By implementing effective processes to separate the best candidates from the rest, you increase the likelihood of hiring only the most suitable candidates for your organisation. Verification checks can validate crucial information such as employment history, educational qualifications and credentials, criminal records, credit history and financial checks, professional licences and certifications, drug and alcohol testing results, reference checks and recommendations, skills assessments and evaluations, and personality and behavioural profiles.

Eliminate Guesswork

Relying solely on impressive resumes and charismatic interviews can lead to hiring subpar performers who disrupt team dynamics and hamper productivity. Thoroughly vetting candidates, checking backgrounds, verifying credentials, and assessing their skills helps you confidently hire new employees without leaving room for chance.

Protect Your Organisation

Think of your organisation as a fortress. However, without proper safeguards, it is vulnerable to various risks. Pre-hire screening acts as the ultimate protection and drawbridge that allows reliable and trustworthy individuals into your company.

Poor hiring decisions can result in disrupted team dynamics, tarnished reputation, lost client trust, and even lawsuits. By meticulously evaluating candidates’ backgrounds, you can escape these nightmares and preserve your company’s competitive image while maintaining a harmonious and secure environment for your hardworking team.

Types of Pre-Screening Methods

There are various pre-screening methods that employers can use throughout the hiring process. Let’s explore different screening methods and when to ideally perform them:

Pre-Interview Screening

Screening candidates early in the application stage helps shortlist individuals with the right skills and qualities. Filtering candidates before interviews ensures that the right talent enters your recruitment pipeline and offers rejected candidates the closure needed to continue their job search elsewhere.

  1. Application and Resume Screening: Your trusty applicant tracking system (ATS) automatically filters candidates based on their applications, saving you time and effort. However, finding the perfect candidate requires a deeper evaluation.

  2. Aptitude Tests: These pre-hire screening tests assess cognitive abilities, problem-solving skills, and critical thinking. Delve into logical reasoning, numerical aptitude, verbal comprehension, and spatial awareness to identify individuals with exceptional intellectual potential.

  3. Behavioural Tests: Behavioural tests measure interpersonal skills, decision-making style, adaptability, and leadership potential to determine candidates’ suitability in a specific setting, team, and organisational culture.

  4. Personality Tests: These evaluations assess traits, preferences, and work styles to gain insight into how candidates approach work, communicate, and collaborate.

Interview Screening

At this stage, you’ll likely have a candidate list meeting the minimum requirements. The next step is conducting interviews to clarify details from resumes and use assessment results to ask strategic interview questions that shed light on candidates’ potential and suitability for the role.

  1. Preliminary Interviews: These interviews serve as an initial screening stage and efficiently evaluate a large candidate pool. Methods like telephonic interviews or recorded video interviews are suitable options.

  2. Official Interviews: Selected candidates proceed to official interviews, often face-to-face or through virtual platforms. This stage involves a more in-depth assessment, and multiple interview rounds may be necessary, especially for senior or specialised roles.

Post-Interview Screening

At this point, you’re nearing the final stage of the hiring process, but thoroughness is key. Validating and verifying candidates’ sources, documents, and history helps thoroughly cross-check candidates’ character and integrity.

  1. Verifications: Essential verification tests include reference and recommendation verification, employment verification, education verification, licencing and professional certification verification, and military service records checks.

  2. Background Checks: Common background checks include social security number trace, civil records search, credit report check, driving records check, drug testing, healthcare sanctions report, and worker’s compensation claims history.

  3. Criminal Records: Search through local, state, and national databases to uncover any criminal convictions or records that a candidate may have.

Which Screening Methods Should You Use?

To determine which screening methods are appropriate for your business, consider the following steps:

  1. Assess your organisation’s specific needs, industry standards, and roles to identify the information required for hiring decisions.
  2. Learn about legal and regulatory requirements, such as anti-discrimination laws and GDPR.
  3. Identify positions that require access to sensitive information, financial assets, or significantly impact security and safety during hiring.
  4. Evaluate various screening methods, considering reliability, accuracy, cost, and turnaround time.
  5. Consult with legal and compliance experts to navigate complex legal issues.
  6. Partner with reputable screening providers with an impressive track record in your industry and workforce type.
  7. Select methods that balance thorough screening with a fair and accessible process for candidates.

How Software Can Help

Implementing the right software can help you ethically and compliantly conduct relevant searches. Here are some software solutions that can assist in managing complex screening processes effectively:

  • Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS): Streamline candidate management, resume parsing, and application tracking, facilitating initial screening based on predefined criteria.
  • Talent Assessment Tools: Utilise various assessment methods like aptitude tests, situational judgement tests, and job simulations to identify top performers and ensure a match between candidates and job requirements.
  • Talent Intelligence Tools: Harness powerful data analytics, AI algorithms, and I/O psychologists to gather and validate insights.
  • Behavioural Assessment Tools: Provide standardised and scientifically validated assessments to evaluate candidates’ behavioural traits, personality traits, and cognitive abilities.
  • Background Check Software: Conduct criminal records, employment verification, and educational credential verification searches to screen candidates thoroughly and reduce administrative burden.

To ensure compliance and fairness throughout the pre-hire screening process, consider the following legal aspects:

  • Comply with applicable privacy laws and regulations like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
  • Obtain proper consent from applicants and handle personal information securely.
  • Consider the nature and gravity of a candidate’s criminal history, the time passed since the conviction, and its relevance to the job before making adverse employment decisions.
  • Be mindful of screening practices that disproportionately impact protected groups based on race, gender, religion, or disability.


To help you understand this vital process, here are answers to some common questions related to pre-employment screening:

  1. What types of pre-employment screening tests are commonly conducted? Standard tests include background checks, drug and alcohol testing, skills assessments, reference and recommendation verifications, cognitive ability tests, personality assessments, and integrity tests.

  2. Are pre-employment screening tests mandatory for all job applicants? The necessity of pre-employment screening tests depends on the employer and the position. Legal or regulatory requirements may mandate specific screenings in industries like healthcare or finance. However, not all companies or jobs may require extensive screening.

  3. How do pre-employment screening tests impact hiring decisions? Screening results, along with other factors like interviews and qualifications, contribute to candidate evaluations. The weight given to pre-employment screening results in the final decision varies amongst employers and depends on the specific job requirements and industry standards.

Next Steps

Now that you understand screening techniques and legal considerations, you can make well-informed decisions and select the right methods for your business. Software solutions can assist in managing complex screening processes effectively.

If you’re ready to implement pre-employment screening processes, please discuss your needs with our colleagues at Expol.

Speak to them for a no-obligation quote today:

Expol Employment Screening

+44 (0)1624 611190

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.  Learn more